Ever since I started playing Magic the Gathering, I have had a deep love for its lore. Whether that was the story of the Thran, the Brothers’ War, Urza and his titans, Sisay and the Weatherlight crew, Glissa and her allies, all the way up to the tales still being created to this day.
While everyone has their favorite storylines in Magic’s thirty-year history, some stories stand out far from the rest. However, it is tough to determine which of them are truly the “best” since a lot of that comes down to personal preference.
Some Magic fans have a love of mecha and familial conflict, drawing them to stories like the Brothers’ War. Others adore Japanese culture and are drawn to the events of the Kami war on Kamigawa. Maybe you fantasize about living on a metallic plane, and the long history of Mirrodin draws your fancy. Or, like me, you are drawn to a specific character (Gerrard) and enjoy following their storyline.
Whatever your reasons are, Magic has something for everyone, which is why it’s been such a beloved game for so many people for such a long time. However, if I were to give you a list of the top ten MTG novels, it would be wildly biased, as I enjoy certain stories and characters more than others.
The good news: we now have a robot to ask all the hard questions! Let’s Ask the AI:
What are the ten best Magic the Gathering Novels ever made?
1. "The Brothers' War"
by Jeff Grubb
The story is set on the plane of Dominaria and revolves around the two powerful artificers, Urza and Mishra, who are brothers. The brothers discover ancient artifacts known as Powerstones, and their desire for power leads to a bitter rivalry. As they unlock the artifacts' secrets, their conflict escalates, and they become central figures in a devastating war that spans generations.
The novel explores the origins of the Magic multiverse and the consequences of the brothers' actions on Dominaria. It delves into themes of power, ambition, and the cost of war, showcasing the impact of the brothers' feud on the world and its inhabitants.
As for why "The Brothers' War" is considered a beloved novel:
Foundational Lore: The novel provides a crucial foundation for the Magic: The Gathering universe by exploring the history of Dominaria and the origins of the game's most iconic characters, Urza and Mishra.
Epic Scale: The story is epic in scope, spanning generations and continents. It incorporates grand themes of war, magic, and the consequences of unchecked ambition.
Character Development: Readers connect with the well-developed characters, particularly Urza and Mishra, as they evolve from talented young artificers to powerful Planeswalkers. The complexities of their relationship add depth to the narrative.
Rich World-Building: Grubb's writing brings the world of Dominaria to life, immersing readers in a detailed and immersive setting. The novel introduces readers to the diverse cultures and landscapes of the plane.
Influence on the Magic Lore: "The Brothers' War" significantly shaped the Magic: The Gathering lore, establishing key elements that continue to influence the game's narrative even years after its publication.
2. "Planeswalker"
by Lynn Abbey
"Planeswalker" by Lynn Abbey centers around the character Urza, one of the most iconic figures in Magic: The Gathering lore. The novel explores Urza's life, his relationships, and his transformation into a planeswalker. It delves into Urza's quest for power, his involvement in the Brothers' War, and his pursuit of ancient artifacts with immense magical capabilities. As the narrative unfolds, readers witness Urza's journey across various planes, gaining insights into the character's motivations, struggles, and the impact of his actions on the multiverse.
As for why "Planeswalker" is considered a beloved novel:
Character Exploration: The novel provides an in-depth exploration of Urza, a central figure in Magic lore. Readers gain a deeper understanding of his complexities, motivations, and the events that shaped him.
Historical Significance: "Planeswalker" contributes significantly to the overarching narrative of the Magic: The Gathering multiverse, particularly in detailing key events and periods in Urza's life.
Connection to Magic Lore: Magic enthusiasts often appreciate novels that add layers to the game's lore, and "Planeswalker" is valued for its contribution to the broader Magic storyline.
3. "Time Streams"
by J. Robert King
"Time Streams" continues the story of the planeswalker Urza as he seeks to manipulate time itself to undo the catastrophic events caused by the Brothers' War. Urza, driven by a desire to prevent further destruction and undo past mistakes, embarks on a perilous journey through different time streams. Along the way, he encounters various versions of himself and other familiar characters, each existing in alternate timelines.
As Urza navigates the complexities of time travel, he faces moral dilemmas, encounters powerful beings, and witnesses the consequences of his actions. The novel weaves together elements of science fiction and fantasy, creating a narrative that spans different eras and explores the consequences of meddling with the fabric of time.
As for why "Time Streams" is considered a beloved novel:
Exploration of Time Travel: "Time Streams" is praised for its ambitious exploration of time travel, a concept that adds a unique and complex layer to the Magic: The Gathering lore. The novel tackles the intricacies and paradoxes associated with manipulating time.
Character Development: Readers appreciate the continued development of Urza's character. The novel provides insight into his motivations, struggles, and the toll that his quest for power and redemption takes on him.
Expansive World-Building: The story spans different time periods and planes, offering readers a broader view of the Magic multiverse. The rich world-building contributes to the overall depth of the Magic lore.
Connection to Larger Arc: "Time Streams" is an integral part of the "Artifacts Cycle" and contributes significantly to the overarching narrative of Magic: The Gathering. It connects events from previous novels and sets the stage for future developments in the storyline.
Blend of Genres: The novel's blend of science fiction and fantasy elements appeals to readers who enjoy a mix of genres. The incorporation of time travel adds a layer of complexity and intrigue to the narrative.
4. "The Thran"
by J. Robert King
"The Thran" is a historical novel that unfolds on the plane of Dominaria, Magic's central setting. The story is set thousands of years before the events of many Magic: The Gathering novels and card sets. The narrative primarily revolves around the rise and fall of the Thran civilization, an advanced and technologically sophisticated society.
As for why "The Thran" is considered a beloved novel:
Foundational Lore: "The Thran" is highly regarded for providing a foundational understanding of the Magic multiverse. It establishes the historical context and origins of key elements that resonate throughout Magic's lore.
Complex Characters: The novel introduces readers to compelling characters, including Yawgmoth, whose actions and motivations have far-reaching consequences. The complexity of characters adds depth to the narrative.
World-Building: J. Robert King's world-building skills shine in "The Thran." The novel paints a vivid picture of the ancient world of Dominaria, capturing the imagination of readers with its detailed descriptions and rich atmosphere.
Impact on Subsequent Lore: Many elements introduced in "The Thran" have had a lasting impact on the Magic: The Gathering narrative. The novel's influence can be seen in later sets, storylines, and character arcs.
Mystery and Intrigue: The novel is known for its sense of mystery and intrigue, keeping readers engaged as they uncover the secrets and events that shape the destiny of the Thran civilization.
5. "Rath and Storm"
by Peter Archer
The story follows the character Gerrard Capashen, a member of the Weatherlight crew, as he finds himself in the plane of Rath. Rath is a plane created by the powerful planeswalker Urza as part of his plan to combat the Phyrexian threat. Gerrard discovers that Rath is a world of shifting landscapes and dangerous creatures, and it is a crucial part of Urza's strategy.
As Gerrard navigates the challenges of Rath, he encounters a complex web of political intrigue, power struggles, and the ongoing conflict between the Phyrexians and their adversaries. The novel explores Gerrard's journey as he strives to understand Rath's mysteries and fulfill his role in the larger plan to combat the Phyrexian threat.
As for why "Rath and Storm" is considered a beloved novel:
Expansion of the Multiverse: "Rath and Storm" is praised for its contribution to the expansion of the Magic: The Gathering multiverse. The novel introduces readers to the unique plane of Rath, offering a fresh and immersive setting for the unfolding narrative.
Weatherlight Crew Dynamics: Fans of the Weatherlight Saga appreciate "Rath and Storm" for its exploration of the dynamics within the Weatherlight crew. The interactions and relationships among crew members, as well as their individual challenges, add depth to the storyline.
Intriguing Plot: The novel is known for its intriguing plot filled with twists and turns. The political intrigue and power struggles on Rath, coupled with the ongoing conflict with the Phyrexians, keep readers engaged and invested in the unfolding events.
Character Development: Gerrard Capashen undergoes significant character development in the novel. Readers witness his growth and challenges as he grapples with the complexities of Rath and the responsibilities placed upon him.
Contribution to Larger Story Arc: "Rath and Storm" is part of the overarching narrative of the Weatherlight Saga and the struggle against the Phyrexians. The novel's events have repercussions that echo through subsequent Magic: The Gathering storylines.
Rich World-Building: Peter Archer's world-building skills are on display in "Rath and Storm," as he crafts a vivid and detailed portrayal of Rath, with its ever-changing landscapes and unique inhabitants.
6. "Invasion"
by J. Robert King
The novel "Invasion" is set during a tumultuous time on Dominaria when the plane is under threat from an invasion by the Phyrexians. The Phyrexians, a malevolent and technologically advanced race, seek to conquer Dominaria and spread their influence across the multiverse. As the inhabitants of Dominaria unite to fend off this invasion, various characters from previous Magic novels, including members of the Weatherlight crew, play key roles in the unfolding events.
The story weaves together multiple plotlines, following the efforts of different factions to resist the Phyrexian threat. The Weatherlight crew, led by Gerrard Capashen, is central to the narrative as they face challenges and make crucial decisions to protect Dominaria. The novel explores themes of war, sacrifice, and the consequences of powerful artifacts and ancient conflicts.
As for why "Invasion" is considered a beloved novel:
Epic Scale: "Invasion" is beloved for its epic scale, capturing the grandeur of a multiverse-spanning conflict. The stakes are high as Dominaria faces an imminent threat, and the novel effectively conveys the sense of urgency and tension.
Integration with the Card Set: The novel is tied to the "Invasion" expansion set in the Magic card game. Fans appreciate how the story in the novel complements and enhances their understanding of the card set, providing context and narrative depth to the game.
Continuation of the Weatherlight Saga: For fans of the Weatherlight Saga, "Invasion" is a crucial installment in the ongoing storyline of Gerrard Capashen and the Weatherlight crew. The novel advances the characters' arcs and addresses the broader narrative established in previous books.
Character Dynamics: "Invasion" explores the dynamics within the Weatherlight crew and other key characters, allowing readers to further connect with and understand the motivations of the protagonists.
Impact on Magic Lore: The events in "Invasion" have lasting consequences for the Magic: The Gathering lore. The novel shapes the course of Dominaria's history and influences subsequent storylines in the Magic multiverse.
Engaging Writing: J. Robert King's writing style is often praised for its ability to capture the essence of Magic's fantastical worlds and characters. The vivid descriptions and engaging prose contribute to the overall enjoyment of the novel.
7. "Nemesis"
by Paul B. Thompson
"Nemesis" is set on the plane of Mercadia, where the Weatherlight crew, led by Gerrard Capashen, faces new challenges and adversaries. The novel follows the crew's attempts to navigate the political complexities of Mercadia, a world divided into city-states, each with its own interests and agendas. As tensions rise and conflicts escalate, the crew discovers a new threat in the form of the Phyrexians, a malevolent race seeking to spread their influence across the multiverse.
Gerrard and the Weatherlight crew must not only contend with the political machinations of Mercadia's rulers but also confront the looming Phyrexian menace. The novel explores themes of power, betrayal, and the consequences of unchecked ambition as the characters grapple with the challenges presented by both political and supernatural forces.
As for why "Nemesis" is considered a beloved novel:
Political Intrigue: "Nemesis" is praised for its engaging exploration of political intrigue on the plane of Mercadia. The novel delves into the complexities of the different city-states and the power struggles that shape the political landscape.
Continuation of the Weatherlight Saga: For fans of the Weatherlight Saga, "Nemesis" is a vital installment in the ongoing narrative. The novel advances the story of Gerrard Capashen and his companions, providing further development for familiar characters.
Introduction of Phyrexian Threat: The inclusion of the Phyrexians adds a layer of suspense and danger to the storyline. The relentless and insidious nature of the Phyrexians creates a compelling and formidable adversary for the Weatherlight crew.
Character Dynamics: "Nemesis" further explores the dynamics among the Weatherlight crew, allowing readers to deepen their connections with the characters. The interactions and relationships contribute to the emotional resonance of the narrative.
Contribution to Magic Lore: The events in "Nemesis" have lasting consequences for the Magic: The Gathering lore, influencing the trajectory of the overall storyline and setting the stage for future developments.
Blend of Genres: The novel successfully blends elements of political fantasy with the overarching themes of Magic: The Gathering. This combination appeals to readers who enjoy intricate plots and fantastical settings.
8. "The Moons of Mirrodin"
by Will McDermott
"The Moons of Mirrodin" follows the character Glissa Sunseeker, a Sylvok, as she embarks on a journey to uncover the mysteries of Mirrodin. Glissa begins to experience unsettling visions and strange phenomena, leading her to believe that Mirrodin is undergoing a transformation. As she explores the various landscapes and encounters the different factions on the plane, she unravels the dark secrets behind Mirrodin's origins and the forces at play.
The novel explores the tension between the organic and the artificial, with Glissa becoming a central figure in the struggle for the plane's survival, facing both internal and external threats.
As for why "The Moons of Mirrodin" is considered a beloved novel:
Exploration of Mirrodin: "The Moons of Mirrodin" is praised for its vivid depiction of Mirrodin, a unique and visually striking plane in the Magic: The Gathering multiverse. The novel delves into the intricacies of Mirrodin's landscape, inhabitants, and the conflicts that shape the plane.
Protagonist's Journey: Glissa Sunseeker's journey is a key aspect of the novel's appeal. Readers connect with her as she grapples with the mysteries of Mirrodin, confronts personal challenges, and takes on a central role in the unfolding events.
Intricate Plot: The novel weaves an intricate and engaging plot, incorporating elements of mystery, exploration, and conflict. The narrative unfolds at a pace that keeps readers invested in the storyline, with unexpected twists and turns.
World-Building: Will McDermott's world-building skills contribute to the overall appeal of the novel. Mirrodin is portrayed as a dynamic and evolving world with a rich history, and readers appreciate the attention to detail in its creation.
Contribution to Magic Lore: "The Moons of Mirrodin" is part of the larger Magic: The Gathering lore, and its events have implications for the ongoing storyline of the game. Fans appreciate novels that contribute meaningfully to the overarching narrative.
9. "Arena"
by William R. Forstchen
"Arena" follows the story of a planeswalker named Garth One-Eye, who is summoned by the powerful planeswalker, Ravidel, to compete in a series of magical battles in the Arena. The Arena is a dimension created by the planeswalker Greensleeves for the purpose of resolving conflicts between planeswalkers without causing devastation to the multiverse.
Garth One-Eye is tasked with facing various opponents, each possessing unique magical abilities and strengths. As he progresses through the battles, Garth uncovers the true nature of the conflicts and the consequences of the duels in the Arena. The novel explores themes of power, sacrifice, and the consequences of wielding magic on a grand scale.
As for why "Arena" is considered a beloved novel:
Historical Significance: "Arena" holds historical significance as one of the first novels in the Magic: The Gathering franchise. It introduces readers to the concept of planeswalkers and the broader multiverse, setting the stage for the game's extensive lore.
Introduction of Planeswalkers: The novel is notable for introducing the character Garth One-Eye as one of the earliest planeswalkers in Magic lore. Planeswalkers are central to the game and its storytelling, and "Arena" played a pivotal role in establishing this concept.
Engaging Storyline: The novel offers an engaging storyline with magical battles, intrigue, and a glimpse into the diverse worlds of the multiverse. It captures the imagination of readers with its fantastical elements and the exploration of different planes.
Character Development: Garth One-Eye undergoes significant character development throughout the novel. Readers witness his growth as he faces challenges in the Arena and grapples with the ethical implications of the conflicts.
Expanding the Multiverse: "Arena" contributes to the expansion of the Magic multiverse by showcasing various planes and realms. This adds depth to the overall lore of the game and appeals to fans interested in exploring the diverse settings of Magic.
Connection to the Game: Fans of Magic: The Gathering appreciate novels that tie into the game's mechanics and card sets. "Arena" is connected to the early sets of Magic cards and complements the gaming experience.
10. "The Gathering Dark"
by Jeff Grubb
"The Gathering Dark" follows the story of Jodah, a mage attending the mage's school at the University of Terisiare. As the Ice Age descends upon Dominaria, magical energy becomes unstable, and Jodah must navigate the challenges posed by the harsh climate and political tensions. The novel explores the consequences of unchecked magical power and the efforts of various factions to survive in a world gripped by ice.
Jodah becomes embroiled in a conspiracy involving the ruling council of mages, and as he unravels the mysteries surrounding the freezing of Dominaria, he discovers the presence of ancient and powerful artifacts that could hold the key to the world's survival.
As for why "The Gathering Dark" is considered a beloved novel:
Exploration of Dominaria during the Ice Age: "The Gathering Dark" is celebrated for its detailed exploration of the plane of Dominaria during a time of extreme magical and environmental upheaval. The novel captures the stark and frozen landscapes, providing a vivid backdrop for the unfolding narrative.
Complex Protagonist: Jodah, the protagonist, is a complex and well-developed character. Readers connect with his struggles, growth, and the moral dilemmas he faces as he becomes entangled in the larger events of the Ice Age.
Political Intrigue: The novel incorporates political intrigue and power struggles among the mage's council, adding depth to the storyline. The political landscape becomes a significant aspect of the plot, contributing to the overall complexity of the narrative.
Ancient Artifacts and Mysteries: The inclusion of ancient artifacts and mysteries engages readers who enjoy discovering the lore of Magic: The Gathering. The novel introduces elements that have lasting repercussions in the broader Magic multiverse.
Contributions to Magic Lore: "The Gathering Dark" is part of Magic's rich lore, contributing to the overarching narrative of the game. The events in the novel have implications for the future storylines and the understanding of Dominaria's history.
Well-Crafted World-Building: Jeff Grubb's skillful world-building brings the frozen world of Dominaria to life. The descriptions of the Ice Age and its impact on the inhabitants create a compelling and immersive reading experience.
"These novels are a mix of stand-alone stories and series that make up Magic's extensive lore. It's worth noting that Magic: The Gathering novels have gone through several publishing phases, so availability may vary, but they can be a great way to delve deeper into the game's rich narrative."
So what do you think? Did the robot get it right? Were any books left off the list that you think deserve to be there? Let us know in the comments below!
Comments